Skip to content
Subscribe and Save 6% Forever on Future Orders!
Subscribe and Save 6% Forever on Future Orders!

Cat Toys

  • Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Wide Cat Toy
    Save $0.96 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Wide Cat Toy

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $3.37
    Original price $3.37 - Original price $3.37
    Original price $3.37
    Current price $2.41
    $2.41 - $2.41
    Current price $2.41

    COLORFUL SPRINGS-WIDE 10/PK SPRING INTO ACTION WITH THESE ZANY DELIGHTS! GREAT SPECIAL IMPULSE ITEM!

    Original price $3.37
    Original price $3.37 - Original price $3.37
    Original price $3.37
    Current price $2.41
    $2.41 - $2.41
    Current price $2.41
    Save $0.96 Save $0.00
  • Ethical Pet Songbird with Catnip
    Save $2.64 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet Songbird with Catnip

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $9.23
    Original price $9.23 - Original price $9.23
    Original price $9.23
    Current price $6.59
    $6.59 - $6.59
    Current price $6.59

    Ethical Pet Songbird with Catnip 5", Assorted colors Assorted plush birds that sing a song when batted around. Made in China.

    Original price $9.23
    Original price $9.23 - Original price $9.23
    Original price $9.23
    Current price $6.59
    $6.59 - $6.59
    Current price $6.59
    Save $2.64 Save $0.00
  • Cosmic Play and Squeak Backyard Animals Cat Toys
    Save $2.75 Save $0.00

    Cosmic Play and Squeak Backyard Animals Cat Toys

    Cosmic
    Original price $9.63
    Original price $9.63 - Original price $9.63
    Original price $9.63
    Current price $6.88
    $6.88 - $6.88
    Current price $6.88

    Cosmic Play n Squeak Backyard BUNNY This is a cat toy that any-bunny can love! It is a fun and furry outlet for your cat's instinctual need to hun...

    View full details
    Original price $9.63
    Original price $9.63 - Original price $9.63
    Original price $9.63
    Current price $6.88
    $6.88 - $6.88
    Current price $6.88
    Save $2.75 Save $0.00
  • Save $1.76 Save $0.00

    Spot Spotnips Colored Catnip Assorted Toys

    Spot
    Original price $6.15
    Original price $6.15 - Original price $6.15
    Original price $6.15
    Current price $4.39
    $4.39 - $4.39
    Current price $4.39

    About the Product: Spot Burlap Mice 3 Pack Assorted is the right size cat toy, the right material cat toy, the right shape (what cat can resist a m...

    View full details
    Original price $6.15
    Original price $6.15 - Original price $6.15
    Original price $6.15
    Current price $4.39
    $4.39 - $4.39
    Current price $4.39
    Save $1.76 Save $0.00
  • Save $4.13 Save $0.00

    Petmate Crazy Circle Cat Toy - Blue

    Petmate
    Original price $14.47
    Original price $14.47 - Original price $14.47
    Original price $14.47
    Current price $10.34
    $10.34 - $10.34
    Current price $10.34

    About the Product: The Petmate Crazy Circle Cat Toy is a tubular plastic track that holds a ball toy for kitty to poke at and chase through paw-siz...

    View full details
    Original price $14.47
    Original price $14.47 - Original price $14.47
    Original price $14.47
    Current price $10.34
    $10.34 - $10.34
    Current price $10.34
    Save $4.13 Save $0.00
  • Save $1.81 Save $0.00

    JW Pet Cataction Catnip Black And White Bird Cat Toy With Feather Tail

    JW Pet
    Original price $6.34
    Original price $6.34 - Original price $6.34
    Original price $6.34
    Current price $4.53
    $4.53 - $4.53
    Current price $4.53

    About the Product: The Cataction Black and White Toy is filled with high-quality catnip to encourage play. This lightweight toy is soft and easy fo...

    View full details
    Original price $6.34
    Original price $6.34 - Original price $6.34
    Original price $6.34
    Current price $4.53
    $4.53 - $4.53
    Current price $4.53
    Save $1.81 Save $0.00
  • Save $1.02 Save $0.00

    JW Pet Cataction Catnip Infused Butterfly Interactive Cat Toy

    JW Pet
    Original price $3.55
    Original price $3.55 - Original price $3.55
    Original price $3.55
    Current price $2.53
    $2.53 - $2.53
    Current price $2.53

    About the Product: The Cataction Catnip Infused Butterfly Interactive Cat Toy is made from durable TPR Rubber and infused with high-quality Made in...

    View full details
    Original price $3.55
    Original price $3.55 - Original price $3.55
    Original price $3.55
    Current price $2.53
    $2.53 - $2.53
    Current price $2.53
    Save $1.02 Save $0.00
  • Save $1.16 Save $0.00

    JW Pet Cataction Catnip Mouse Cat Toy With Rope Tail

    JW Pet
    Original price $4.04
    Original price $4.04 - Original price $4.04
    Original price $4.04
    Current price $2.88
    $2.88 - $2.88
    Current price $2.88

    About the Product: The Cataction Catnip Mouse Cat Toy With Rope Tail is infused and filled with catnip, producing a strong aroma that drives cats c...

    View full details
    Original price $4.04
    Original price $4.04 - Original price $4.04
    Original price $4.04
    Current price $2.88
    $2.88 - $2.88
    Current price $2.88
    Save $1.16 Save $0.00
  • Save $1.14 Save $0.00

    JW Pet Cataction Catnip Plush Monkey Cat Toy

    JW Pet
    Original price $4.00
    Original price $4.00 - Original price $4.00
    Original price $4.00
    Current price $2.86
    $2.86 - $2.86
    Current price $2.86

    About the Product: The Cataction Catnip Plush Monkey Cat Toy is a super-soft plush toy is infused with catnip that produces a strong aroma that dri...

    View full details
    Original price $4.00
    Original price $4.00 - Original price $4.00
    Original price $4.00
    Current price $2.86
    $2.86 - $2.86
    Current price $2.86
    Save $1.14 Save $0.00
  • Save $1.14 Save $0.00

    JW Pet Cataction Catnip Plush Raccoon Cat Toy

    JW Pet
    Original price $4.00
    Original price $4.00 - Original price $4.00
    Original price $4.00
    Current price $2.86
    $2.86 - $2.86
    Current price $2.86

    About the Product: The Cataction Catnip Plush Raccoon Cat Toy is a super-soft plush toy is infused with catnip that produces a strong aroma that dr...

    View full details
    Original price $4.00
    Original price $4.00 - Original price $4.00
    Original price $4.00
    Current price $2.86
    $2.86 - $2.86
    Current price $2.86
    Save $1.14 Save $0.00
  • Save $1.07 Save $0.00

    JW Pet Cataction Crunchy Butterfly Cat Toy

    JW Pet
    Original price $3.76
    Original price $3.76 - Original price $3.76
    Original price $3.76
    Current price $2.69
    $2.69 - $2.69
    Current price $2.69

    About the Product: The Cataction Crunchy Butterfly Cat Toy has crunchy materials on the inside that produce a crackly, crunchy sound that cats love...

    View full details
    Original price $3.76
    Original price $3.76 - Original price $3.76
    Original price $3.76
    Current price $2.69
    $2.69 - $2.69
    Current price $2.69
    Save $1.07 Save $0.00
  • Save $1.20 Save $0.00

    JW Pet Cataction Feather Ball Interactive Cat Toy

    JW Pet
    Original price $4.18
    Original price $4.18 - Original price $4.18
    Original price $4.18
    Current price $2.98
    $2.98 - $2.98
    Current price $2.98

    About the Product: The Cataction Feather Ball Toy is sure to be a new favorite addition to your cat's stash of toys. Designed with your cats well-b...

    View full details
    Original price $4.18
    Original price $4.18 - Original price $4.18
    Original price $4.18
    Current price $2.98
    $2.98 - $2.98
    Current price $2.98
    Save $1.20 Save $0.00
  • Save $1.24 Save $0.00

    JW Pet Cataction Feather Ball Toy With Bell Interactive Cat Toy

    JW Pet
    Original price $4.33
    Original price $4.33 - Original price $4.33
    Original price $4.33
    Current price $3.09
    $3.09 - $3.09
    Current price $3.09

    About the Product: The Cataction Feather Ball With Bell is sure to be a favorite new addition to your cat's stash of toys. This multi-textured cat ...

    View full details
    Original price $4.33
    Original price $4.33 - Original price $4.33
    Original price $4.33
    Current price $3.09
    $3.09 - $3.09
    Current price $3.09
    Save $1.24 Save $0.00
  • Save $0.96 Save $0.00

    JW Pet Cataction Fish Ball Interactive Cat Toy

    JW Pet
    Original price $3.35
    Original price $3.35 - Original price $3.35
    Original price $3.35
    Current price $2.39
    $2.39 - $2.39
    Current price $2.39

    About the Product: The Cataction Fish Ball is a colorful plastic ball with rattle beads and bright colorful fish inside. Perfect to roll, bat, swat...

    View full details
    Original price $3.35
    Original price $3.35 - Original price $3.35
    Original price $3.35
    Current price $2.39
    $2.39 - $2.39
    Current price $2.39
    Save $0.96 Save $0.00
  • Save $1.86 Save $0.00

    JW Pet Catnip Feather Boa Squeaky Catnip Toy

    JW Pet
    Original price $6.50
    Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price $6.50
    Current price $4.64
    $4.64 - $4.64
    Current price $4.64

    About the Product: The Squeaky Feather Boa is a fluffy, feathery, bundle of fun. This interactive toy is a long strip of bright and colorful interw...

    View full details
    Original price $6.50
    Original price $6.50 - Original price $6.50
    Original price $6.50
    Current price $4.64
    $4.64 - $4.64
    Current price $4.64
    Save $1.86 Save $0.00
  • Save $0.76 Save $0.00

    Petmate Classic Kitten Little Cat Toy Assorted Colors

    Petmate
    Original price $2.65
    Original price $2.65 - Original price $2.65
    Original price $2.65
    Current price $1.89
    $1.89 - $1.89
    Current price $1.89

    About the Product: Kitten Little toys will throw even the most Potato-Like (as in lumpy couch potato) cats into a sweet frenzy of the highest level...

    View full details
    Original price $2.65
    Original price $2.65 - Original price $2.65
    Original price $2.65
    Current price $1.89
    $1.89 - $1.89
    Current price $1.89
    Save $0.76 Save $0.00
  • Coastal Pet Products Turbo Replacement Twinkle Ball
    Save $2.40 Save $0.00

    Coastal Pet Products Turbo Replacement Twinkle Ball

    Coastal Pet Products
    Original price $8.39
    Original price $8.39 - Original price $8.39
    Original price $8.39
    Current price $5.99
    $5.99 - $5.99
    Current price $5.99

    Light up your cat's playful side with the Turbo® Replacement Twinkle Ball! This ball toy features a motion-activated light for added stimulation du...

    View full details
    Original price $8.39
    Original price $8.39 - Original price $8.39
    Original price $8.39
    Current price $5.99
    $5.99 - $5.99
    Current price $5.99
    Save $2.40 Save $0.00
  • Coastal Pet Products Turbo Ball Glitter Pom Poms Cat Toys
    Save $1.00 Save $0.00

    Coastal Pet Products Turbo Ball Glitter Pom Poms Cat Toys

    Coastal Pet Products
    Original price $3.49
    Original price $3.49 - Original price $3.49
    Original price $3.49
    Current price $2.49
    $2.49 - $2.49
    Current price $2.49

    Give your cat hours of play and exercise with Turbo® Assorted Ball Cat Toys! These toys are made from a variety of engaging materials, including f...

    View full details
    Original price $3.49
    Original price $3.49 - Original price $3.49
    Original price $3.49
    Current price $2.49
    $2.49 - $2.49
    Current price $2.49
    Save $1.00 Save $0.00
  • Ethical Pet Fishing Rod n Reel Kitty Teaser
    Save $3.52 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet Fishing Rod n Reel Kitty Teaser

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $12.31
    Original price $12.31 - Original price $12.31
    Original price $12.31
    Current price $8.79
    $8.79 - $8.79
    Current price $8.79

    Ethical Pet Fishing Rod n Reel Kitty Teaser Fishing Rod & Reel Kitty Teaser features a real casting action with clicking sound, a telescopic r...

    View full details
    Original price $12.31
    Original price $12.31 - Original price $12.31
    Original price $12.31
    Current price $8.79
    $8.79 - $8.79
    Current price $8.79
    Save $3.52 Save $0.00
  • Ethical Pet Atomic Bouncing Ball
    Save $1.24 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet Atomic Bouncing Ball

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $4.33
    Original price $4.33 - Original price $4.33
    Original price $4.33
    Current price $3.09
    $3.09 - $3.09
    Current price $3.09

    The atomic bouncing ball's unique shape makes them bounce in every direction, driving your cat crazy. Your cat will love the special bumpy shape, a...

    View full details
    Original price $4.33
    Original price $4.33 - Original price $4.33
    Original price $4.33
    Current price $3.09
    $3.09 - $3.09
    Current price $3.09
    Save $1.24 Save $0.00
  • Ethical Pet Kitty Fun Tubes Cat Toy
    Save $1.48 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet Kitty Fun Tubes Cat Toy

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $5.17
    Original price $5.17 - Original price $5.17
    Original price $5.17
    Current price $3.69
    $3.69 - $3.69
    Current price $3.69

    3 piece bright & colorful kitty fun tubes made with springy mesh for interactive play. Catnip pouch inside each tube. Fun texture for a cat’s c...

    View full details
    Original price $5.17
    Original price $5.17 - Original price $5.17
    Original price $5.17
    Current price $3.69
    $3.69 - $3.69
    Current price $3.69
    Save $1.48 Save $0.00
  • Ethical Pet Fur Mice-Cat Toys (Assorted Colors)
    Save $1.72 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet Fur Mice-Cat Toys (Assorted Colors)

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $6.01
    Original price $6.01 - Original price $6.01
    Original price $6.01
    Current price $4.29
    $4.29 - $4.29
    Current price $4.29

    The Classic Fur Mouse come in assorted colors. The all-time kitty favorite. Fashionably hued for hours of playtime fun. **imitation fur**

    Original price $6.01
    Original price $6.01 - Original price $6.01
    Original price $6.01
    Current price $4.29
    $4.29 - $4.29
    Current price $4.29
    Save $1.72 Save $0.00
  • Ethical Pet Songbird Teaser Wand
    Save $2.64 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet Songbird Teaser Wand

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $9.23
    Original price $9.23 - Original price $9.23
    Original price $9.23
    Current price $6.59
    $6.59 - $6.59
    Current price $6.59

    Ethical Songbird Teaser Wand Assorted plush birds on a teaser wand that sing a song when batted. Made in China

    Original price $9.23
    Original price $9.23 - Original price $9.23
    Original price $9.23
    Current price $6.59
    $6.59 - $6.59
    Current price $6.59
    Save $2.64 Save $0.00
  • Ethical Pet SPOT LED Motion Activated Cat Ball Toy
    Save $1.52 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet SPOT LED Motion Activated Cat Ball Toy

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $5.31
    Original price $5.31 - Original price $5.31
    Original price $5.31
    Current price $3.79
    $3.79 - $3.79
    Current price $3.79

    The LED Motion Activated Cat Ball has motion activated LEDs for hours of play.

    Original price $5.31
    Original price $5.31 - Original price $5.31
    Original price $5.31
    Current price $3.79
    $3.79 - $3.79
    Current price $3.79
    Save $1.52 Save $0.00
  • Ethical Pet Wool Pom Poms with Catnip Cat Toy
    Save $0.94 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet Wool Pom Poms with Catnip Cat Toy

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $3.31
    Original price $3.31 - Original price $3.31
    Original price $3.31
    Current price $2.37
    $2.37 - $2.37
    Current price $2.37

    Four multi-colored wool pom poms that contain catnip.

    Original price $3.31
    Original price $3.31 - Original price $3.31
    Original price $3.31
    Current price $2.37
    $2.37 - $2.37
    Current price $2.37
    Save $0.94 Save $0.00
  • Ethical Pet I Am Not A Dog Cat Indoor Hunting Feeder Kit
    Save $8.00 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet I Am Not A Dog Cat Indoor Hunting Feeder Kit

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $27.99
    Original price $27.99 - Original price $27.99
    Original price $27.99
    Current price $19.99
    $19.99 - $19.99
    Current price $19.99

    Ethical Pet "I Am Not A Dog" Cat Indoor Hunting Feeder Kit The Indoor Hunting Feeder allows cats to eat the way nature intended and has helped tho...

    View full details
    Original price $27.99
    Original price $27.99 - Original price $27.99
    Original price $27.99
    Current price $19.99
    $19.99 - $19.99
    Current price $19.99
    Save $8.00 Save $0.00
  • Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Thin Cat Toy
    Save $1.28 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Thin Cat Toy

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $4.47
    Original price $4.47 - Original price $4.47
    Original price $4.47
    Current price $3.19
    $3.19 - $3.19
    Current price $3.19

    COLORFUL SPRINGS THIN 10/PK SPRING into ACTION with THESE ZANY DELIGHTS! GREAT IMPULSE ITEM!

    Original price $4.47
    Original price $4.47 - Original price $4.47
    Original price $4.47
    Current price $3.19
    $3.19 - $3.19
    Current price $3.19
    Save $1.28 Save $0.00
  • Ethical Pet SPOT Feather Boa Teaser Wand with Catnip Toy
    Save $1.28 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet SPOT Feather Boa Teaser Wand with Catnip Toy

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $4.47
    Original price $4.47 - Original price $4.47
    Original price $4.47
    Current price $3.19
    $3.19 - $3.19
    Current price $3.19

    This boa teaser wand comes in an assortment with 6 different fun characters and colors. Each contains catnip.

    Original price $4.47
    Original price $4.47 - Original price $4.47
    Original price $4.47
    Current price $3.19
    $3.19 - $3.19
    Current price $3.19
    Save $1.28 Save $0.00
  • Ethical Pet SPOT Mylar Balls Cat Toy
    Save $1.11 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet SPOT Mylar Balls Cat Toy

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $3.90
    Original price $3.90 - Original price $3.90
    Original price $3.90
    Current price $2.79
    $2.79 - $2.79
    Current price $2.79

    1.5" 4-pack mylar balls that make a crinkle sound that cats love.

    Original price $3.90
    Original price $3.90 - Original price $3.90
    Original price $3.90
    Current price $2.79
    $2.79 - $2.79
    Current price $2.79
    Save $1.11 Save $0.00
  • Ethical Pet SPOT Skinneeez Forest Creatures Cat Toys
    Save $1.76 Save $0.00

    Ethical Pet SPOT Skinneeez Forest Creatures Cat Toys

    Ethical Pet
    Original price $6.15
    Original price $6.15 - Original price $6.15
    Original price $6.15
    Current price $4.39
    $4.39 - $4.39
    Current price $4.39

    Skinneeez Forest Animals Cat Toys come in one of three animals; Skunk, Squirrel, or Mouse. **Let us choose which forest creature your cat will e...

    View full details
    Original price $6.15
    Original price $6.15 - Original price $6.15
    Original price $6.15
    Current price $4.39
    $4.39 - $4.39
    Current price $4.39
    Save $1.76 Save $0.00